Natural Gas Generators vs. Diesel Generators: Which is Right for You?

Diesel and natural gas are the primary fuels for industrial generators, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Diesel generators are known for their durability and efficiency, while natural gas generators offer lower emissions and reduced fuel costs.

When selecting a generator, it is crucial to consider factors such as cost, efficiency, lifespan, maintenance requirements, and emissions to ensure you choose the appropriate fuel for your needs.

Main Differences Between Diesel and Natural Gas Generators?

The primary differences between natural gas generators and diesel generators lie in their fuel sources and methods of energy generation. Natural gas generators ignite a mixture of fuel and air using spark plugs, whereas diesel generators generate heat through the compression of air in the cylinder, subsequently igniting a small amount of diesel fuel.

Both types of generators offer excellent power solutions, whether for primary power, backup power, or portable power. They are suitable for a wide range of applications, including hospitals, construction sites, communities, schools, homes, and data centers.

Pros & Cons of Diesel Generators

Pros

Versatility and Reliability: Diesel generators can operate in virtually any location as long as diesel fuel is available. This makes them ideal for remote construction sites, ships, and areas without access to the power grid. They are also a reliable backup power source during blackouts.

Durability and Maintenance: Diesel generators are known for their long lifespan and durability. They generally require less maintenance than natural gas generators, contributing to lower long-term maintenance costs. Diesel engines are robust and built to withstand harsh conditions, making them suitable for demanding applications.

Safety and Fuel Stability: Diesel fuel is less flammable compared to natural gas, reducing the risk of fire or explosion. Additionally, diesel fuel can be stored on-site, ensuring a continuous supply during emergencies or natural disasters when other fuel supplies might be interrupted.

Power Density: Diesel fuel has a higher energy density than natural gas, meaning that diesel generators are more power-dense and can generate more electricity from the same volume of fuel. This can be particularly advantageous for high-power applications.

Pros & Cons of Natural Gas Generators

Pros

Environmental Benefits: Natural gas is a cleaner burning fuel compared to diesel, with lower emissions of sulfur, nitrogen oxides, and carbon dioxide. This makes natural gas generators more environmentally friendly and helps reduce your carbon footprint.

Cost-Effective Operation: Natural gas is generally less expensive than diesel fuel, leading to lower operational costs. The abundance of natural gas and its delivery through pipelines also means fewer storage requirements and potentially lower fuel costs.

Lower Noise and Odor: Natural gas generators tend to be quieter and produce less odor compared to diesel generators. This makes them more suitable for residential areas and settings where noise and smell could be a concern.

Convenience of Supply: In metropolitan areas, natural gas is delivered directly through underground pipelines, eliminating the need for on-site fuel storage and reducing the risk of running out of fuel during emergencies.

Cons

Fuel Supply Dependence: Natural gas generators rely on a continuous supply from pipelines, which can be disrupted during natural disasters or emergencies. This dependency can be a significant drawback if you need a reliable power source during such events.

Higher Initial Cost: Natural gas generators can be more expensive to purchase and install compared to diesel generators, especially if a dedicated natural gas supply or storage system is required.

Flammability and Safety Concerns: Natural gas is highly flammable and poses a risk of explosion if there are leaks or if the generator catches fire. Ensuring safety requires diligent maintenance and monitoring of gas connections.

Size and Space Requirements: Natural gas generators are typically larger than diesel generators, which can be an issue if space is limited. Their size may also make them less suitable for portable or small-scale applications.

How to Choose the Right Generator?

Based on the above summary, it is evident that both diesel and natural gas generators offer distinct advantages and disadvantages. Diesel generators are celebrated for their durability, reliability, and higher power density, making them suitable for a broad range of applications, particularly in scenarios where fuel storage and stability are critical. However, they are typically noisy and produce higher emissions.

Conversely, natural gas generators are more environmentally friendly and economical in terms of fuel, emitting lower noise and odor levels. They are ideal for regions with a reliable natural gas supply. Nonetheless, they tend to be more expensive to install and are vulnerable to interruptions in the fuel supply.

Choosing between diesel and natural gas generators depends on your specific needs, budget, and the reliability of the fuel supply in your area. Selecting the appropriate type of generator based on these factors and application scenarios ensures a dependable and cost-effective electricity supply.

Cost Considerations

Historically, diesel generators have had a significant cost advantage, but with natural gas suppliers offering more competitive prices, the cost gap is narrowing. Although the initial purchase cost of diesel generators is usually higher, their efficiency and longer lifespan can make them more economical in the long term.

Conversely, natural gas generators have lower initial costs and cheaper operating expenses since natural gas is typically less expensive than diesel, though they may not be as durable as diesel generators. Therefore, from a long-term perspective, the cost difference can be negligible, requiring a balanced consideration based on specific applications and budget.

Efficiency

Diesel generators are more efficient than natural gas generators in terms of energy conversion because diesel engines ignite fuel through compression. Diesel has a peak energy density of 129 Btu, compared to 37 Btu for natural gas, meaning each unit of diesel contains more energy.

Typically, diesel generators are 20-40% more efficient than natural gas generators because diesel engines can generate more power with less fuel. This high energy density makes diesel generators more cost-effective for long-term operation and allows them to run at higher capacities, providing a more stable power supply.

Lifespan

The lifespan of diesel generators is generally twice that of natural gas generators because they can withstand higher temperatures and pressures and are less prone to degradation. Diesel generators usually employ a liquid cooling system, which is more effective than air cooling, reducing equipment wear and tear.

Operating at a lower 1800 RPM, diesel generators consume less fuel and experience less part wear. In contrast, natural gas generators typically run at 3600 RPM, resulting in higher long-term maintenance costs. The durability and lower operating temperature of diesel generators make them reliable power sources for various applications.

Maintenance Requirements

Diesel generators typically require less maintenance due to their simpler internal structure, lacking spark plugs and carburetors. Major maintenance tasks include checking and replacing filters, oil levels, belts, hoses, coolant levels, and batteries, with frequencies depending on running time.

Natural gas generators require more maintenance, especially for fuel filters and spark plugs, as natural gas is more volatile and can clog the engine. Natural gas generators depend on pipeline supply, which may be disrupted by natural disasters.

Emissions Comparison

Natural gas generators are more environmentally friendly than diesel generators. Natural gas emits 116.65 pounds of CO2 per million Btu, compared to 163.45 pounds for diesel. Natural gas generators produce about 30% fewer CO2, NOx, and particulate emissions than diesel generators.

Although diesel generators have significantly reduced particulate and NOx emissions since 2015 under EPA standards, natural gas generators are still preferred for their cleaner emissions. Diesel generator exhaust is toxic and odorous, typically requiring outdoor use, while natural gas generators are odorless and better suited for indoor or near-building applications.

Fuel Storage and Supply

Diesel generators rely on on-site fuel tanks, which can be affected by weather and logistics. Tanks can be either base tanks (adding 8 inches of height) or day tanks (capable of storing up to 10,000 gallons). Diesel requires periodic treatment to remain effective.

Natural gas generators are powered by pipelines, suitable for urban areas, but remote regions and extreme weather can disrupt supply. Natural gas generators do not require additional fuel storage, making them ideal for environments with a stable fuel supply.

Noise Levels

Diesel generators are typically noisier than natural gas generators, particularly in residential or urban environments. While advanced soundproofing technologies can reduce the noise of diesel generators, the lower noise levels of natural gas generators make them more suitable for places where a quiet environment is essential.

Installation and Space Requirements

Diesel generators are more compact and suitable for installation in small spaces. Natural gas generators may require additional space for gas storage and ventilation systems. Therefore, site space and layout considerations are essential when choosing the generator type.

Safety

Diesel is relatively safe, as it is not highly flammable and leaks are easily detected and managed. Natural gas, however, is highly flammable and toxic, requiring careful safety measures in case of leaks. Although natural gas incidents are rare, evacuation and notifying fire departments are necessary if a natural gas leak occurs.

Choosing the Right Size Generator for Your Business

As a business owner or manager, collaborating with industry experts is crucial when purchasing a commercial generator. These experts can assess your energy needs and recommend the most suitable equipment type. Even if you are already familiar with the advantages and disadvantages of natural gas and diesel generators, acquiring a significant amount of machinery can still be a daunting experience.

Powerlink offers a wide range of natural gas and diesel generators to meet various power requirements. We not only provide comprehensive maintenance services but also offer professional advice to ensure your chosen generator remains in optimal condition. Contact us today for personalized recommendations and ensure your business has a stable power supply.

--- END ---